Book Review: 'Alfred Hitchcock Presents: Stories My Mother Never Told Me'
3 / 5 Stars
Well, here we go with another vintage Alfred Hitchcock anthology, published by Dell in 1965. The cover artist is uncredited, but may be Fred Banbery. All of the stories compiled in this anthology first saw print from 1927 to 1962.
My capsule summaries of the contents:
The Child Who Believed, by Grace Amundson: Armitage, a down-at-heels magician, performs at a children's party. He imparts occult knowledge to a little girl named Constance. There is irony in the closing paragraphs.
Just a Dreamer, by Robert Arthur: Arthur, who would edit a large number of Hitchcock anthologies, pens this tale of a mild-mannered husband named Wilfred Weem. Wilfred has the unusual ability to bring into reality, the inanimate objects he sees in dreams. His wife, a grasping woman, seeks to leverage this ability. An interesting premise for a story, but Arthur avoids doing much with it, other than invoking a mild, darkly comic sensibility.
The Wall-to-Wall Grave, by Andrew Benedict: Morton, a mild-mannered, but meticulous, man decides to take revenge on the Sports Bro who ruined his daughter. One of the grimmer, and better, tales in the anthology.
Witch's Money, by John Collier: not a horror, suspense, or crime story, but a fable about a little village in the Pyrenees Mountains, and the consequences of unfettered greed.
The Secret of the Bottle, by Gerald Kersh: Ambrose Bierce decides to investigate a strange mansion located in the mountains of the Yucatan. This, despite warnings from the locals that the place is to be avoided. A good story from Kersh. Like Shirley Jackson's tale (below) it relies on growing unease to generate suspense, but does so in a more impactful manner.
A Short Trip Home, by F. Scott Fitzgerald: a mild ghost story involving college students, home for Christmas vacation to Minneapolis-St. Paul. First published in 1927, it was aged even by the standards of 1965 when it was republished in this Hitchcock anthology.
An Invitation to the Hunt, by George Hitchcock: Fred Perkins, an otherwise unremarkable resident of the Marine Gardens subdivision, receives an invitation to participate in a hunt hosted by the imposing country club a few blocks away. I suspect most readers will guess where this story goes, quite early on.
The Summer People, by Shirley Jackson: Janet and Robert Allison decide that, rather than returning to their New York city apartment come Labor Day, they will stay on for a few more months at their rural cottage. The local people do not seem enthused to hear this. This story's plot device is the same as that of Kersh's tale (above), but lacks its edgier quality.
Adjustments, by George Mandel: Caroline's husband Peter is on a tenure track at the local university. This is a good thing, but then again, Peter does have those moments where he gets a little........excitable. This story's labored pacing and wordiness keep it from being impactful. Have a dictionary handy for 'marcescent,' 'elusion,' 'captious,' and 'oscitant.'
The Children of Noah, by Richard Matheson: At 3 a.m. Mr. Ketchum speeds through Zachry, Maine, population 67, and is startled to be pulled over by the local police. They place the indignant Mr. Ketchum in jail, and are vague about when he’ll be released. But they do take care to provide him with a wonderful breakfast in the morning.....
The Idol of the Flies, by Jane Rice: Pruitt is a little boy and a Bad Seed, a true Demon Child. He delights in abusing the four elderly people in his household: Miss Bittner, the tutor; Harry, the handyman; Bertha, the cook; and Aunt Mona, the home's owner. Disturbingly, Pruitt may have an alliance with something old, and evil...... This story has an offbeat premise, but is hampered by its use of pulp-style prose, and a dilatory narrative.
Hostage, by Don Sanford: Pat Cochrane, aka Pasquale Cocciani, is not a mobster, but in fact, a Legitimate Businessman who, in past years, associated with people from the more colorful walks of life. These past associations turn out to be a double-edged sword. A clever tale, and one of the best in the anthology.
Smart Sucker, by Richard Wormser: Henry Croft, a salesman of office products, is in the less pleasant part of the city when a rainstorm obliges him to seek shelter in a nearby dive bar. The lowlife patrons of the bar are pleased to see Henry, as they have something in mind that requires the use of a 'sucker'.......
This story first was published in 1957 in Manhunt magazine,whose publisher, Flying Eagle Publications / HSD, also published Alfred Hitchcock's Mystery Magazine. Manhunt was intended as a showcase for hardboiled crime fiction, and 'Smart Sucker' certainly has a noir sensibility. Unfortunately its denouement relies too heavily on contrivance and coincidence.
Summing up, 'Stories My Mother Never Told Me' is one of the less impressive Hitchcock anthologies. It's the entries from Benedict, Kersh, Hitchcock, Matheson, and Sanford that push my Rating to Three Stars. If you're a fan of the Hitchcock anthologies this volume may be worth picking up, but all others likely can pass without penalty.