Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Book Review: The Pines by Robert Dunbar

Book Review: 'The Pines' by Robert Dunbar
 
0 / 5 Stars
 
'The Pines' (359 pp.) was published by Leisure Books in May 1989. It was author Dunbar's first published novel, and the first of three volumes in his 'Pines' trilogy, the other entries being 'The Shore' (2007) and 'The Streets' (2015). 
 
Dunbar is the author of over 30 books, most of these in the horror and suspense genres. Along with the novels, he has edited several anthologies, as well as 'Vortex' (2013), a collection of essays on horror themes and tropes. Dunbar maintains his own self-publishing imprint, Uninvited Books, which offers various horror titles in print-on-demand and Kindle versions.
 
I've read some mediocre Paperbacks from Hell in my day, but 'The Pines' is one of the most medicore........it is bad. 
 
The novel is set in the late 1980s in the Pine Barrens of New Jersey. As was common in Paperbacks from Hell, in the opening pages the reader is introduced to the violent and brutal demise of a vagrant / prostitute / hitch-hiker / wayward child by 'something.' 
 
Something......EVIL !!!!!!!!!!
 
We then segue to the initial chapters of 'The Pines,' these serving to introduce a large cast of characters, and to communicate the peculiar atmosphere and setting of the Barrens. 
 
It's summertime, and the Barrens are sweltering: amid the humid heat, mosquitos swarm and thunderstorms drench the countryside. For lead character Athena Monroe, times are difficult. Athena, a single mom, lives with her disabled son Mat in a ramshackle house in the hamlet of Munro's Furnace. Athena earns a modest living as a member of the county ambulance service (a plot device which gives the author opportunities to ladle some splatterpunk scenes onto the narrative).
 
As the summer unfolds, and the reports of 'disappearances' and found corpses pile up, Athena and her fellow 'pineys' come to the realization that someone, or something (perhaps the mythical 'Jersey Devil' ?) is on a rampage in the Barrens. The pineys can expect little assistance from the remainder of the state, so it will be up to them to band together and confront the horror that stalks the Barrens by night.........
 
However promising its premise, 'The Pines' completely misfires, mainly due to its excessive length (it needs to be at least 100 pages shorter) which is padded out with interminable dialogue passages and a profoundly overwritten prose style. For author Dunbar, even someone getting up in the morning has to be rendered as a highly descriptive, simile-packed Event: 
 
She pulled on a robe and padded down the hall, then, at a sink stained blue and orange, smoothed the sleep from her face with a washcloth. Putrid noises emanated from the plumbing. The towel smelled of mildew, and the odor mingled strongly with that of soap. While the leaky faucet pattered, the runneled pane of the window rattled, and vines over the back of the house rustled like the wings of startled pigeons. Bedroom walls curled, peeling like lizard skin, and in the corners lay hair and dust and flakes of plaster.
 
After slogging through 339 pages of overheated prose, I was relieved when the denouement finally arrived, on page 340. However, the denouement was so incoherent that I had to read it several times before I could figure out just what, exactly, the Jersey Devil was. I won't give away any spoilers, but there was a contrived quality to the entire Devil narrative. I finished the novel thinking I'd been given scant reward for putting up with a rambling, unfocused storyline.

The verdict ? There are plenty of Paperbacks from Hell that are much more rewarding than 'The Pines.'  

[ I note that there are a number of reviews of 'The Pines' available online and some of these give out spoilers. But all have a more approving opinion of the novel than do I. ]

No comments: